Oracle Australia Wins Pause in $253 Million Royalty Tax Case

Scalar comment:

Another case where likely the use of Mutual Agreement Procedures becomes critical.

1. Issue & What Was at Issue

Issue:
Oracle Australia is disputing the Australian Taxation Office’s (ATO) position that certain intercompany license fees constitute royalties subject to withholding tax.

What was at issue:

• The legal question is centered on whether Oracle should be allowed to stop domestic proceedings to pursue MAP, and how this relates to broader disputes on embedded royalties, an area under active scrutiny in Australia.
• The ATO alleges that payments between Oracle Australia and Oracle Ireland (2013–2018) included embedded royalties requiring withholding tax, totalling A$253 million in tax and penalties.
• Oracle is seeking to pause the ATO’s enforcement action so it can instead use the Mutual Agreement Procedure (MAP) under the Australia–Ireland tax treaty.

2. Present Result / Current Outcome

• The Federal Court of Australia overturned a 2024 decision and granted Oracle a stay, allowing it to use the MAP process.
• This halts the ATO’s A$253 million royalty withholding tax case for now.
• The court rejected arguments that continuing the ATO case would:
  • Provide clarity to 15 similar ongoing cases, or
  • Help resolve tensions between Australia and the US over royalty definitions.
• A decision regarding legal costs is still pending.

3. To-Dos / Expectations / Next Steps

For Oracle:

• Proceed with the MAP under the Australia–Ireland treaty to negotiate the dispute internationally.
• Await the court’s decision on costs.

For the ATO:

• Prepare for MAP engagement and potential coordination with Irish authorities.
• Continue revising its draft software and embedded royalty guidance, particularly in light of:
  • The Pepsi court loss earlier in the year, and
  • The Federal Court’s rejection of its arguments in this case.

Broader expectations:

• The ruling may encourage other taxpayers facing royalty disputes to pursue MAP.
• The ATO’s position on embedded software royalties is likely to continue evolving, with implications for at least 15 similar pending cases.
• The US–Australia friction over royalty classifications remains unresolved.

Turn transfer pricing into a strategic advantage. From planning and documentation to dispute resolution, our team helps you optimize your global tax position while minimizing risk.

VIEW TRANSFER PRICING SERVICES